ES-108 Stage Manifest¶
Manifest purpose¶
This manifest is the structured contract for ES-108.
Stage identity¶
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Stage ID | ES-108 |
| Stage Name | Code Review and Integration |
| Stage Family | Construction Execution |
| Stage Type | Review, integration, and evidence production |
| Estimated Effort | 1–2 hours per integration increment |
| Prerequisites | ES-107 — AI-Assisted Implementation |
| Previous Stage | ES-107 — AI-Assisted Implementation |
| Next Stage | ES-109 — Testing and Verification |
| Primary Output | Code review and integration evidence package |
| Publication Status | Production-ready |
Stage mission¶
Review, verify, integrate, and preserve evidence for implementation changes before they become part of the shared baseline.
Primary engineering question¶
Is the implemented work safe, traceable, verified, reviewed, and ready to integrate into the shared engineering baseline?
Inputs¶
| Input | Required | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Implementation log | Yes | docs/implementation/implementation_log.md |
| AI assistance log | Conditional | docs/implementation/ai_assistance_log.md |
| Work item completion records | Yes | docs/implementation/work_item_completion_records.md |
| Implementation evidence | Yes | docs/implementation/implementation_evidence.md |
| Verification notes | Yes | docs/implementation/verification_notes.md |
| Implementation decision records | Conditional | docs/implementation/implementation_decision_records.md |
| Implementation risk updates | Yes | docs/implementation/implementation_risk_updates.md |
| Implementation summary | Yes | docs/implementation/implementation_summary.md |
Outputs¶
| Output | Repository Location |
|---|---|
| Code review overview | docs/integration/code_review_overview.md |
| Pull request review record | docs/integration/pull_request_review_record.md |
| Traceability review | docs/integration/traceability_review.md |
| AI implementation review | docs/integration/ai_implementation_review.md |
| Guardrail review | docs/integration/guardrail_review.md |
| Integration plan | docs/integration/integration_plan.md |
| Integration verification record | docs/integration/integration_verification_record.md |
| Review findings | docs/integration/review_findings.md |
| Integration decision record | docs/integration/integration_decision_record.md |
| Integration readiness summary | docs/integration/integration_readiness_summary.md |
Required evidence¶
- review scope evidence;
- pull request review evidence;
- traceability review evidence;
- AI implementation review evidence where applicable;
- guardrail review evidence;
- integration planning evidence;
- integration verification evidence;
- review finding evidence;
- integration decision evidence;
- transition evidence.
Completion criteria¶
ES-108 is complete when review scope is clear, PR review evidence exists, traceability is reviewed, AI-assisted implementation is reviewed where applicable, guardrails are checked, integration plan exists, integration verification is recorded, review findings are resolved or accepted, integration decision is explicit, and ES-109 readiness is documented.
Success criteria¶
ES-108 succeeds when ES-109 can begin testing and verification without guessing what changed, why it changed, how it was reviewed, what was integrated, or what risks remain.
Risks if skipped¶
Skipping ES-108 may result in unreviewed code, AI-generated defects, weak traceability, guardrail violations, integration instability, hidden risks, and unfocused testing.