Code Review Overview¶

Library AreaTemplate Library

Current PageCode Review Overview

FocusReview Scope

UseEngineering Review

Repository Areadocs/template-library/integration/

← Back Implementation Summary

Current Code Review Overview

Next → Pull Request Review Record

Template purpose¶

Use this template to define the review scope before reviewing PRs, branches, implementation evidence, AI assistance, guardrails, and integration risk.

Project¶

<Project name>

Document control¶

Field	Value
Artifact owner	`<owner>`
Primary reviewers	`<reviewers>`
Status	`<draft / in review / accepted / revised>`
Last updated	`<YYYY-MM-DD>`
Related Engineering Stage	`ES-108 — Code Review and Integration`
Project workspace target	`docs/project-workspace/integration/code_review_overview.md`

Review scope¶

<Describe what is being reviewed.>

Source implementation evidence¶

docs/project-workspace/implementation/implementation_log.md
docs/project-workspace/implementation/ai_assistance_log.md
docs/project-workspace/implementation/work_item_completion_records.md
docs/project-workspace/implementation/implementation_evidence.md
docs/project-workspace/implementation/verification_notes.md
docs/project-workspace/implementation/implementation_summary.md

Work items reviewed¶

Work Item	Summary	Implementation Evidence	Status
`<IW-ID>`	`<summary>`	`<evidence>`	`<ready / incomplete / blocked / deferred>`

Pull requests / branches¶

PR / Branch	Purpose	Work Items	Author	Review Status
`<PR or branch>`	`<purpose>`	`<IW IDs>`	`<author>`	`<status>`

Changed areas¶

Area	Changed?	Notes
Components	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Interfaces	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Data structures	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Workflows	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Access control	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
AI behavior	`<yes / no / partial / not applicable>`	`<notes>`
Evidence production	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Error handling	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Configuration / deployment	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`
Documentation	`<yes / no / partial>`	`<notes>`

Review objectives¶

Objective	Evidence Needed
`<objective>`	`<evidence>`

Known risks entering review¶

Risk	Source	Review Focus
`<risk>`	`<source>`	`<focus>`

Review strategy¶

Review Domain	Reviewer	Evidence
Functional correctness	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
Architecture/design conformance	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
Traceability	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
Guardrails	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
AI-assisted implementation	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
Security/privacy/access	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
Verification	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`
Repository state	`<reviewer>`	`<evidence>`

Acceptance criteria¶

<criterion>

Review checklist¶

[ ] Review scope is clear.
[ ] Source implementation evidence is identified.
[ ] Work items and PRs/branches are listed.
[ ] Changed areas are identified.
[ ] Review objectives and acceptance criteria are defined.
[ ] Risks entering review are visible.
[ ] Reviewer responsibilities are assigned.

Continue to Pull Request Review Record

Proceed to the next ES-108 integration artifact.

Open Pull Request Review Record →